An overview of the ethical issues of human cloning in the modern world

Back to Text In order to be sure that we explore fully the human meaning of cloning, we shall examine it in comparison with natural unaided human reproduction, rather than assisted reproduction, say, with in vitro fertilization. A clearer and more thoughtful awareness of the aims of biomedical science could help us assess whether and how human cloning might serve the ends of science and medicine and could help us more fully consider its possible benefits and potential drawbacks.

We consider the likely medical benefits, the potential social and ethical difficulties, and the concern over the treatment of human embryos. And, on the other hand, how can science and technology be protected against unreasonable limitations imposed by excessively fearful legislators or overzealous regulators?

Yet there has always been some disagreement about the lengths to which we should allow ourselves to go in serving them.

In order to grapple with the ethical implications of cloning and genetic engineering, we need to confront questions largely lost from view in the [End Page ] modern world—questions about the moral status of nature and about the proper stance of human beings toward the given world.

The key ethical issue with therapeutic cloning is the moral status of the cloned embryo, which is created solely for destruction. Cloning and Biomedical Science Human procreation is not the only context for evaluating the prospect of human cloning.

For example, is the need to discover new cures for the sick a moral imperative that should trump all other goods and values?

The ethics of human cloning /

It determines the relations between one generation and the next, shapes identities, creates attachments, and sets up responsibilities for the care and rearing of children and the care of aging parents or other needy kin.

National Bioethics Advisory Commission, Therapeutic cloning is cloning for purposes other than the live birth of an individual, and has seen support by some governments and many individuals. Finally, this endowment comes to the cloned child not by chance but by human choice and decision.

In Chapter Five we discuss the ethical arguments for and against human cloning-to-produce-children.

To the extent that the research necessary to develop human cloning will likely cause the deaths of human beings, the cost is unacceptably high.

To the contrary, public opinion and almost all elected officials oppose it. In the United States, several attempts have been made to initiate a comprehensive public review of the significance of human cloning and to formulate appropriate policies.

The problem with such a utilitarian approach to human beings, however, is that they are made in the image of God Gen. Ruse M and Aryne S eds Cloning: Increasingly, these ethical issues have spawned public discussion and debates.

Wilson believes that a child obtained by in vitro fertilization or adoption has as good a chance of being lovingly nurtured by its parents as it would have if sexually conceived by them. While the cloning of non-mammals has occurred in research contexts for many years, the cloning of the first mammal, Dolly the sheep, surprised many in the scientific community.

It therefore forces us to ask what might be the difference between begetting and making, to wonder whether cloning somehow crosses the line between them, and, if so, to consider whether and why that should worry us. Lessons and Teachings from a Lifetime in Golf in not only size but also in the truths that are revealed.

And precisely because the use of technologies often has unintended or undesirable side effects, affecting many human goods in addition to health, safety, and the relief of suffering, large questions are necessarily raised when the goods promoted by technology come into conflict with others.

What moral boundaries should scientists and technologists respect as they continue their quests for knowledge and cures, whether or not they receive public funding? Human embryonic stem cells had not yet been isolated at the time of the NBAC report, so the Commission did not offer any recommendations on cloning-for-biomedical-research.

Increasingly, they also are providing precise and sophisticated knowledge of the workings of the human body and mind. Cloning techniques might provide an even more useful source of embryos for biomedical research than current IVF techniques.

Ethics of cloning

Cloning-to-produce-children has never been successfully carried out in humans, and cloning embryos for biomedical research has not progressed beyond the earliest experiments.

For cloning-to-produce-children, while it may be a potential aid to human reproduction, appears also to be a substitute for it, or at least for its natural, un-programmed, sexual character. Oxford and Portland, OR: Ronald Dworkin, for example argues that there is nothing wrong with the ambition "to make the lives of future generations of human beings longer and more full of talent and hence achievement.

Chapter Four summarizes selected aspects of the current state of the relevant science and technology. Even if the purposes it might serve are worthy, it must still be evaluated as a means. In Chapter Four we present a survey of the scientific aspects of human and animal cloning. Our society has come to a near-total agreement on the need for such an agency and the importance of its work.

But I want also to advance a more general claim: Yet they are very close to the surface of the current debate about human cloning. The Vatican said that the claims expressed a mentality that was brutal and lacked ethical consideration.In the extremely readable and interesting introduction, the history and actual ethical dilemmas involving human cloning are offered without the side issues and unscientific debate that seems to be a part of other books of this kind.

The Ethical Implications of Human Cloning Department of Government,Harvard University, Cambridge Street,Cambridge,MA, modern world—questions about the moral status of nature and about the proper the heart of the ethical killarney10mile.com moral problem with reproductive cloning lies.

A look at the ethical issues in cloning. by NeeleshBhandari in Types > Books - Non-fiction, Science, and Medicine HUMAN CLONING ETHICAL ISSUES HUMAN CLONING 11 The world community provided an answer when it declared human cloning contrary to human dignity, in Article 11 of the Universal Declaration on the Human Genome and Human 4/4(1).

Human Cloning and Human Dignity: An Ethical Inquiry Table of Contents. The President's Council on Bioethics Washington, D.C. July killarney10mile.com Chapter One The Meaning of Human Cloning: An Overview. The prospect of human cloning i burst into the public consciousness infollowing the announcement of the successful cloning.

The ethical issues with reproductive cloning include genetic damage to the clone, health risks to the mother, very low success rate meaning loss of large numbers of embryos and fetuses, psychological harm to the clone, complex altered familial relationships, and commodification of human life.

In order to grapple with the ethical implications of cloning and genetic engineering, we need to confront questions largely lost from view in the [End Page ] modern world—questions about the moral status of nature and about the proper stance of human beings toward the given world.

Since questions such as these verge on theology, or at.

Download
An overview of the ethical issues of human cloning in the modern world
Rated 5/5 based on 2 review